In less than a year interval, we had two of the most hyped action RPG titles ever released: Elden Ring and Hogwarts Legacy. Both open-world titles became an overwhelming success, sold millions of copies worldwide, and brought the traditional role-playing experience to a whole new level.

The magical world of Harry Potter already had a considerable number of fans, so an AAA game in this universe was already expected to be a success, especially when considering everything that was promised. On the other hand, the success of Elden Ring was a surprise for many gamers.

From Software games have always been successful but niche titles. On the other hand, Elden Ring broke this tradition and reached the entire gaming community, not only the soulslike players.

This makes it difficult to choose which of the two titles to go with, but don’t worry. In this article, we will compare the main aspects of both worlds to see which one best suits you.

Everything from the game’s narrative to the game’s setting will be explained to ensure you make the right choice. Notice that both titles are available at RoyalCDKeys for a special price. This way, you get to enjoy them and still save money.

• Release Date: February, 2022

• Developer: From Software

• Platforms: Playstation 4, Playstation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, and Microsoft Windows

Elden Ring is From Software’s most ambitious and massive release ever, keeping the traditional action RPG gameplay and dark fantasy setting of the previous Dark Souls games. The game is open-world, allowing you to explore every inch of this enormous environment however you like.

When it comes to narrative versus exploration, Elden Ring is perfectly balanced. The more you explore, the more NPCs you’ll find, and they’ll help you understand what’s happening in this world you’re in.

It follows the story of the main character, known as tarnished. You must seek the Elden Ring in order to become the new Elden Lord and lift the veil of shadows that is currently lying around the Lands Between.

Elden Ring lies on a deep lore explained through dialogues with other characters, the items you find, and the different scenarios you’ll explore. It is a must-play for any soulslike fan.

Get Elden Ring Steam CD key on RoyalCDKeys.

• Release Date: February, 2023

• Developer: Avalanche Software

• Platforms: PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Nintendo Switch, and Microsoft Windows

Harry Potter was one of the most hyped releases of the new generation of consoles, with the key difference between this and previous HP titles being the open-world factor. As expected from a game in this universe, it takes place in the Hogwarts wizardry school and allows you to experience all the scenarios and aspects we love from the movie franchise.

Even though it is an “open-world” title, sometimes you’re limited to linear quest restriction boundaries, which might be frustrating, but after some time, you’ll surely be able to access the desired areas.

It perfectly balances story versus exploration but it has completely opposite takes compared to Elden RIng when it comes to the storytelling. Here, it is way more explicit and easy to understand, even if you don’t explore or do side quests.

You’ll take the role of a Hogwarts student who, with the help of teachers and other students, will unveil a dark secret involving the wizardry world. Be careful because you’ll make many enemies along the way that’ll do anything to stop you.

If you’re a fan of the movie franchise, this is a must-play. Grab your magic wand and start learning your spells.

Get Hogwarts Legacy Steam CD key on RoyalCDKeys.

Now, we will compare the two titles in a series of aspects for you to decide which one best suits what you’re looking for. Take a look at each item to ensure you choose the perfect game that will entertain you for hours.

Here are the main aspects you should consider when comparing Hogwarts Legacy vs. Elden Ring:

Since both experiences are open-world games, comparing their maps and exploration is vital. One of the main aspects of Elden Ring is that its entire map is open for the player to explore from the very beginning. You can go anywhere and use the marked waypoint path to help locate the desired places. Even though you can explore every place, you won’t be able to see where you are on the map tab unless you get the necessary fragment. The game features a piecemeal map reveal effect that expands once you collect these fragments.

On the other hand, Hogwarts Legacy has an emergent open-world experience where most areas are locked at the beginning of the gameplay, but you’ll gradually unlock them. The open-world setting of HL is fairly smaller compared to Elden Ring, but since most of the gameplay revolves around the storytelling and the quests you’ll find along the way, this doesn’t affect the experience.

Elden Ring has colorful and distinguished biomes that it is impossible not to notice when entering a new region. Both games have great exploration, but Hogwarts Legacy allows you to fly across the map, which can be handy for traveling long distances.

Even though you can fly from one point to another, Elden Ring still has a much more diverse and vast world to explore. The enemies variety and the scenarios make it feel fresh in every new area you discover. Harry Potter features a big world with awesome scenarios, but there are not many different enemies to fight against.

Another common aspect between both titles is that the main character is fully customizable. Hogwarts Legacy has fairly more cosmetics and accessories options, like glasses, for example. On the other hand, Elden Ring has a much more detailed customization tab where you can edit even the minimum details of your character’s face. This also allows you to make some crazy creations, like characters that look more like aliens than humans. 

This doesn’t mean you can edit the details in Hogwarts Legacy. Both games share a similar character creation system. But Elden Ring offers more detailed options, while Hogwarts Legacy offers more cosmetic alternatives.

There’s no clear winner in this category, and it’ll depend on what you want when customizing your character. If you want to customize the minimum details of its face and appearance, go for Elden Ring. On the other hand, if you want to use cosmetics, like glasses, Harry Potter is what you want.

Another clear difference between both titles is the combat. In Hogwarts Legacy, spells are your primary offensive resource and practically the only one. In Elden Ring, you can rely on spells as an offensive, support, or defensive tool. Still, you also have a vast arsenal of melee weapons to help you defeat the environment diversity of enemies.

Speaking of weapons, Elden Ring counts on more than a hundred different melee options and a vast volume of ranged tools to deal damage, including spells, bows, and crossbows. Unlike Elden Ring, Hogwarts Legacy restricts the player to the magic wand and some limited throwing items, which is not bad if you like this type of combat that is more focused on long-range battles.

It is no surprise that Elden Ring wins easily when it comes to combat. It features more than 200 different weapons, giving it an enormous variety of fighting options. Whether you want to use a giant sword and slash your enemies or use a bow to take them down from far away, Elden Ring has exactly the kind of weapon you want.

On Hogwarts Legacy, you’re limited to spells, and even though there’s a variety of them, it’ll be your primary way of fighting enemies from the beginning to the end. If you’re not a wizardry fan, this might be a big problem during the gameplay.

Comparing spells is a valid point since both games rely on this resource for many aspects during the gameplay. The result of this comparison is really surprising.
Even though this is the main aspect of Hogwarts Legacy and the entire Harry Potter universe, Elden Ring has almost four times the number of spells available for the player. It has 101 different spells, while HL features only 26, including unforgivable curses and other types of magic abilities.

This makes Elden Ring a much more versatile title that can be enjoyed for endless hours thanks to this variety. Even though ER surpasses Hogwarts Legacy in the number of magic spells, the wizardry title has incredible combat, and, unlike Elden Ring, each spell is very different from the other.

If you want the biggest spells variety, Elden Ring is also a winner here. You’ll find over a hundred different sorceries you can use, going from offensive to support spells. You can also balance between melee weapons and sorceries when fighting, increasing the number of possibilities.

Boss fights are From Software’s specialty, so it is normal for Elden Ring to have a clear advantage over Hogwarts Legacy. The dark fantasy adventure features over 80 bosses to defeat, including some hard-lock boss fights that will give the player a true challenge to beat. 

Most of these bosses are optional and are found during side quests or when exploring the map. Your primary goal is to defeat the Lords, so these are the ones you can’t escape fighting against.

Hogwarts Legacy has a much smaller number of boss fights, which are considerably easier, but this doesn’t mean they’re not fun. They can be challenging depending on the selected difficulty and are climax moments during the narrative progression.

The challenging boss fights also are an aspect that makes Elden Ring another point ahead of Hogwarts Legacy. Most HL boss battles don’t offer a real challenge when compared to the dark fantasy RPG, and winning them is not as rewarding.

Defeating a boss in ER shows how much you have evolved as a player and helps the player to see the evolution of their character’s attributes as you level them up. This, combined with the enormous amount of bosses the game offers, makes Elden Ring a much better option if this is what you’re looking for.

The way both games tell the main story is also pretty different. 

Elden Ring follows the same formula as the other titles of the company, where dialogues only tell part of the story, and to fully understand what’s happening, the player will have to explore much more. From NPCs waiting across the map to items you find along the way, every detail tells a piece of the story, so make sure to explore the entire map if you want to understand the universe’s lore.

Elden Ring also follows the same rigid side-quests formula of the previous titles, where NPCs with requests will be available to talk to across the map. To find them, you must complete the requirements, which go from having a specific item to visiting the place at a determined hour of the day.

Harry Potter features more varied side quests that can go from NPC dialogues to extensions of the main questline. Completing the side quests in both games can lead to more bosses and finding loot with rare items.

In the wizarding world, these items can go from cosmetics to documents to help with the story set. In Elden Ring, most side quests are rewarded with equipment, going from rings to new spells and weapons.

If you’re looking for good storytelling, Hogwarts Legacy is probably the best option to go with. Elden Ring has more lore than storytelling since discovering what’s happening in this universe is not as simple as talking to NPCs. The wizardry title has a great story pacing that keeps the player immersed in from the beginning to the end of the game.

There’s no right or wrong regarding which game you should play. It will depend on the type of game you want to play and what you seek when choosing a title. If you’re a fan of Harry Potter and love the wizardry and witchcraft universe from the books, you’ll definitely love the game. 

It has a great story with catchy characters and a lot of things to explore in the vast coastal and wooded highlands where it takes place. You’ll also find many dungeons to explore, and it is one of the best games for players who like magic-driven combat.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for a challenge with bosses that will take all of your skills to defeat, the colorful biomes of Elden Ring might be the best option for you. You can become a sorcerer like in HL but can also use swords, hammers, bows, and many other types of weapons. The dark fantasy setting with the masterpiece soundtrack composed for this game makes it one of the best RPGs ever created.

But among both options, when comparing the different aspects, Elden Ring has a clear advantage. It not only offers a bigger variety of equipment and spells but also has a much bigger world to explore and a longer experience. You can spend hundreds of hours exploring the Middle Grounds, and you’ll also find something new, like a side quest or a hidden dungeon. 

Elden Ring also has enormous replayability since you can have multiple endings and take different actions depending on the questlines you choose to follow. On the other hand, Harry Potter has incredible characters but almost no replayability since the questlines will always be the same.

As we mentioned, both games can be found on our web page with a special price to ensure you enjoy them while saving money. But why RoyalCDKeys is the best option for your gameplay?

We have over a thousand titles available from all genres and types to ensure you find exactly what you’re looking for. On top of that, we also offer 24-hour support to every key sold, ensuring you’ll redeem them without any problems. Whether you’re looking for a console party game or a dark fantasy RPG, we have everything you need in one place.

Elden Ring and Hogwarts Legacy might look like completely different games, but they actually share a lot in common, like spell casting and a vast world to explore. Both titles generated enormous hype around them and sold millions of copies worldwide, making the competition between them even bigger, even with a one-year gap between releases.

If you’re unsure which one to play, check the items listed above to see the game that best suits you. If you’re looking for a good narrative that’ll make you feel like you’re in a Harry Potter book, Hogwarts Legacy is a great option. If you want to slay enormous bosses and challenge yourself with punitive gameplay, make sure to try Elden Ring.

Now it’s time for you to choose your next fantasy experience. Start learning your sorceries and prepare for battle with all types of creatures.